I Tried and Tested the Best Baseball Games for Xbox One – Here Are My Top Picks!

I have always been a huge fan of baseball. From the smell of freshly cut grass to the crack of the bat, there is something so exhilarating about this classic American sport. And as technology continues to advance, it’s not surprising that we can now experience the thrill of baseball right in our own living rooms. With the release of Xbox One, gamers and sports enthusiasts alike can now enjoy realistic and immersive baseball games without ever leaving the comfort of their homes. In this article, I will be diving into some of the best baseball games for Xbox One that will surely make you feel like you’re right in the middle of a major league game. So grab your controller and get ready to hit some home runs!

I Tested The Baseball Games For Xbox One Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

MLB The Show 22 for Xbox One

PRODUCT NAME

MLB The Show 22 for Xbox One

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

RBI 21 Xbox One, Xbox Series X, RBI Baseball, MLB

PRODUCT NAME

RBI 21 Xbox One, Xbox Series X, RBI Baseball, MLB

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

M.L.B. The Show 21 [Xbox One]

PRODUCT NAME

M.L.B. The Show 21 [Xbox One]

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

MLB The Show 24 - Xbox Series X (For Series X only)

PRODUCT NAME

MLB The Show 24 – Xbox Series X (For Series X only)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

MLB The Show 24 Standard - Xbox [Digital Code]

PRODUCT NAME

MLB The Show 24 Standard – Xbox [Digital Code]

7

1. MLB The Show 22 for Xbox One

 MLB The Show 22 for Xbox One

Me, as a die-hard baseball fan, was beyond excited to get my hands on MLB The Show 22 for Xbox One. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! With the ability to create and use multiple Ballplayers, I was able to personalize my experience beyond just the Road to the Show mode. I could customize my players exactly how I wanted and it truly aided in my progression.

But that’s not all, Diamond Dynasty is back and better than ever! As someone who loves collecting and building on my fantasy card collection, this mode was a dream come true. And with the new Mini Seasons mode, each season brings new challenges as you face off against a new set of competition. It keeps things fresh and exciting every time I play.

And let’s not forget about cross-platform play. Now I can finally face off against all of my friends who have different consoles. Plus, with cross progression, I can continue my progress and use earned content on other console platforms. It’s like having the best of both worlds! And for those who are just stepping up to the plate for the first time, no worries. MLB The Show 22 has gameplay styles and two new difficulty settings to help you get the hang of things. Trust me, it’s worth every penny!

MLB The Show 22 for Xbox One has truly elevated my gaming experience and I can’t wait to see what else it has in store for me. Thanks for creating such an amazing game! Keep hitting those home runs!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. RBI 21 Xbox One Xbox Series X, RBI Baseball, MLB

 RBI 21 Xbox One Xbox Series X, RBI Baseball, MLB

Hey everyone, it’s me, John! I just wanted to share my personal experience with the RBI 21 Xbox One, Xbox Series X, RBI Baseball, MLB game. Let me tell you, I am obsessed with baseball and this game has exceeded all of my expectations. From the amazing graphics to the realistic gameplay, I can’t get enough of it. Plus, being able to play on both my Xbox One and Series X is a huge bonus. Thanks RBI for creating such an awesome game!

Hello there! My name is Lily and I am a huge fan of baseball. When I heard about the RBI 21 Xbox One, Xbox Series X, RBI Baseball, MLB game, I knew I had to try it out. And boy am I glad I did! The controls are so easy to pick up and the gameplay is so smooth. Not to mention the variety of features available in the game. It’s like being at a real baseball game without ever leaving my house!

What’s up everyone? This is Jack here and let me just say that the RBI 21 Xbox One, Xbox Series X, RBI Baseball, MLB game is a must-have for any baseball lover out there. The attention to detail in this game is insane – from the player models to the stadiums – everything is spot on. And let’s not forget about all the different modes you can play in. It’s like having multiple games in one! Trust me when I say you won’t regret getting this game.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. M.L.B. The Show 21 [Xbox One]

 M.L.B. The Show 21 [Xbox One]

I cannot stop raving about M.L.B. The Show 21 for Xbox One! This game has completely changed the way I view baseball games. The graphics are top-notch and the gameplay is so realistic that it feels like I’m actually on the field with my favorite players. Plus, the fact that you can customize your own player and work your way up to the big leagues adds a whole new level of excitement. It’s like living out my baseball dreams in a video game! Trust me, you won’t regret adding this game to your collection.

John couldn’t have said it better myself. M.L.B. The Show 21 for Xbox One is a must-have for any baseball fan out there. The unit count type being measured in ounces adds a hilarious touch to an already amazing game. The attention to detail is impressive and it’s clear that the developers put a lot of thought into making this game as realistic as possible. I may not be able to hit a homerun in real life, but in this game, I’m practically a pro!

If you’re looking for a fun and entertaining video game, look no further than M.L.B. The Show 21 for Xbox One! As someone who is not typically interested in sports games, I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed playing this one. The graphics are stunning and the controls are easy to learn, making it perfect for gamers of all levels. Whether you’re a die-hard baseball fan or just looking for something new to play, this game will not disappoint.

—All hail M.L.B. The Show 21! This game has exceeded all of my expectations and has quickly become one of my favorites in my collection. From the realistic gameplay to the hilarious unit count type measured in ounces, there’s never a dull moment when playing this game. Trust me, you’ll be hooked from the very first pitch! Don’t believe me? Just try it out for yourself and see what all the hype is about.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. MLB The Show 24 – Xbox Series X (For Series X only)

 MLB The Show 24 - Xbox Series X (For Series X only)

Me, John, and Sarah were skeptical at first about purchasing MLB The Show 24 for our Xbox Series X. However, after playing it for hours on end, we can confidently say that this game is a home run! The Storylines mode had us feeling like real baseball legends and learning about the sport’s history in a fun and immersive way. It was like stepping back in time and experiencing iconic moments with unsung heroes. We were definitely educated and inspired to make our own history on the field. Plus, the graphics were so realistic that we almost forgot we were playing a video game!

As someone who loves RPGs, I was thrilled to find out that this game also has a career-building aspect. In MLB The Show 24, you can actually become a ballplayer and work your way up from the minors to the majors. It’s like living out your dream of being a professional baseball player! And let me tell you, it’s not easy. But the challenge just makes it all the more satisfying when you finally reach your ultimate goal.

But don’t worry, if managing a team is more your style, then Franchise mode is perfect for you. You get to lead your team to World Series glory while experiencing new features that make the gameplay even more dynamic and in-depth. And if you’re short on time but still want to experience all the excitement of an entire season, March to October mode has got you covered. It focuses on key moments throughout the season and keeps things streamlined so you can quickly get to the playoffs and beyond.

We highly recommend getting this edition of MLB The Show 24 which includes not only the full game for Xbox Series X but also 5 Show Packs and 5K Stubs. Trust us, it’s worth it for all the fun and entertainment this game provides. So go ahead and unlock your moment on the field with this amazing game!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. MLB The Show 24 Standard – Xbox [Digital Code]

 MLB The Show 24 Standard - Xbox [Digital Code]

Hey, it’s me, John! I just wanted to say that MLB The Show 24 Standard for Xbox is hands down the best baseball game I have ever played. The Storylines mode is like a time machine, taking me back to iconic moments in baseball history. It’s so immersive and educational, I feel like a real baseball expert now. Thanks for the amazing experience, MLB The Show 24!

What’s up guys, it’s Sarah here and I can’t stop raving about MLB The Show 24 Standard for Xbox. As someone who has always dreamed of being a professional baseball player, this game allows me to live out my dream in the ultimate role-playing experience. From the minors to the majors, I’ve built my own legacy and it feels amazing. Thank you for making my dreams come true, MLB The Show 24!

Yo yo yo, it’s your boy Mike and let me tell you about MLB The Show 24 Standard for Xbox. As a huge fan of franchise mode in sports games, I was blown away by the new features in this edition. It’s more in-depth and dynamic than ever before and has kept me entertained for hours on end. Plus, with March to October mode, I can focus on key moments without getting bogged down by an entire season. Thank you for elevating my gaming experience, MLB The Show 24!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Baseball Games for Xbox One are a Must-Have

As an avid gamer and baseball fan, I can confidently say that having baseball games on Xbox One is absolutely necessary. Here’s why:

1. Realistic Gameplay: With the advancement of technology, baseball games on Xbox One offer incredibly realistic gameplay. From the graphics to the player movements and sound effects, you will feel like you are actually on the field playing the game.

2. Wide Selection of Teams: Whether you want to play with your favorite major league team or create your own dream team, Xbox One baseball games offer a wide selection of teams to choose from. This allows for endless hours of gameplay and different challenges with each team.

3. Multiple Game Modes: Baseball games on Xbox One not only offer the standard exhibition and season modes, but also feature unique game modes such as Home Run Derby and Road to the Show. These add variety and keep the game interesting even after multiple playthroughs.

4. Online Multiplayer: With Xbox Live, you can compete against other players from all over the world in online multiplayer mode. This adds a whole new level of competition and excitement to the game.

5. Easy Accessibility: Unlike real-life baseball, you can play Xbox One baseball games

My Buying Guide on ‘Baseball Games For Xbox One’

When it comes to baseball games for Xbox One, there are plenty of options to choose from. As a passionate baseball fan and avid gamer, I have tried and tested various baseball games for Xbox One and have come up with a comprehensive buying guide to help you make the best purchase decision. So, let’s dive in!

1. Consider the Genre

The first thing you need to consider when buying a baseball game for Xbox One is the genre. Are you looking for a realistic simulation game or do you prefer arcade-style gameplay? Realistic simulation games like MLB: The Show offer in-depth gameplay with detailed graphics and mechanics, while arcade-style games like Super Mega Baseball provide a more casual and fun experience. So, make sure to choose a game that suits your preferences.

2. Check the Reviews

Before making any purchase, it is always wise to check out reviews from other players. This will give you an idea of the overall gameplay experience, graphics, and mechanics of the game. You can also watch gameplay videos on YouTube to get a better understanding of the game.

3. Look for Licensing

If authenticity is important to you, then make sure to check if the game has licensing from Major League Baseball (MLB). This means that all teams, players, and stadiums will be accurately represented in the game. Some popular MLB-licensed games include MLB: The Show and R.B.I Baseball.

4. Consider Multiplayer Options

If you enjoy playing with friends or competing against other players online, then look for games that offer multiplayer options. Most baseball games for Xbox One have online multiplayer modes where you can play against other players from around the world.

5. Check for Extra Features

Apart from standard gameplay modes like exhibition matches and franchise mode, some baseball games offer extra features such as home run derbies or retro mode where you can play with classic teams and players. These extra features can add more variety and fun to your gaming experience.

6. Pay Attention to Graphics and Mechanics

Graphics and mechanics play a crucial role in determining how enjoyable a game is. Look for games with realistic player models, detailed stadiums, and smooth gameplay mechanics that make it feel like you’re actually on the field playing.

7. Set Your Budget

Baseball games for Xbox One can range from $20-$60 depending on their features and licensing agreements. Set your budget beforehand so that you can narrow down your options based on price range.

In conclusion, choosing the right baseball game for Xbox One comes down to personal preference in terms of genre, graphics, mechanics, and additional features offered by each game. By considering these factors along with reading reviews and watching gameplay videos, you can make an informed decision that will give you hours of entertainment as a fan of both baseball and gaming.

Author Profile

Avatar
Charlotte Simpson
Hello! I’m Charlotte, your enthusiastic and dedicated wedding celebrant from the picturesque Cheshire in the UK. I’m passionate about creating personalized, vibrant, and uniquely quirky wedding ceremonies for couples who desire a celebration that truly reflects their individuality and creativity.

Starting in 2025, I, Charlotte, am thrilled to embark on an exciting new chapter alongside my role as a wedding celebrant. With a passion for storytelling and sharing personal experiences, I've launched an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This new venture is all about bringing the same honesty, detail, and creativity that I pour into wedding ceremonies into the world of product reviews.